So I resisted getting a Facebook account for like a year, figuring that hey, I may have an LJ, but I am DEFINITELY too old for that shit.
Then my comm arts prof made fun of me–well, indirectly. But he made a pointed remark yesterday about what happens to people who fail to adopt new technologies. Naturally, I have sort of a misplaced pride in not being That Guy (although: see my unnatural devotion to MUSIC, which faded after 1999 only because my undergrad institution took it away), and I know my sister Sophie uses it pretty obsessively, so I went and made a Facebook account yesterday.
And promptly discovered that not only do multiple grad students in my department have them, but so does my FATHER. Geeze. So much for being the technological innovator in the family.
Then I went to the doctor’s office this morning to get my INR checked, and while I was in the elevator with several people, one of them turned to me and said: “Hey, aren’t you on MySpace?”
Uh, yeah. Yeah, I am. Only because of my old friend Laura, who uses it to blog. I think it has a shitty interface, so I don’t use it much. But this is the second time I’ve been in an elevator* and had someone who I thought was a stranger recognize me from the interweb–and turn out to be someone to whom I am pretty much directly virtually connected.
My comm arts prof remarked yesterday that as networking systems like Friendster and Facebook add blogs and other features, the boundaries between different kinds of internet presence are breaking down. Reflecting on that–it’s probably true–I think one reason I never found the network sites particularly interesting is that I already used LJ, which had very good features for keeping an online journal (particularly filters and commenting, for me), but was also strongly focused on networks already–that’s a major difference between LJ and, say, Blogspot.
In recent months, of course, SixApart has been actively working to make LJ even more like the network sites, adding new fields to the info page like schools attended, and adding features like the ScrapBook (which, dude, talk about a shitty interface, but I get a lot of space on it with my permanent account).
Despite all this, however, LJ remains pretty ghetto-ized in a lot of ways. I think sites like Facebook probably draw a lot more “casual users.” For one thing, they’re not inextricably linked in the minds of many internet users with bad goth poetry written by self-pierced 15-year-old girls who can’t spell. They’re also not billed as being FOR blogging/journaling, which of course a lot of people have no interest in anyway.
On the other hand, this may give LJ an edge when it comes to actually reaping benefits from the network–as long as non-users don’t pay enough attention to it to create actual harmful effects (”we can’t hire HIM, he has a LIVEJOURNAL”), being part of a smaller network might mean stronger ties to other members overall: a kind of underdog team mentality.
One thing for which I use LJ that might work better–but I’m not sure about this–on, say, Facebook, are the kind of general bulletin posts that I make to my Madison filter when I need a ride to the grocery store, or the one I made this morning to my entire friends list, asking someone who already had my phone number to please call it, because I couldn’t find my cell phone.** That kind of thing may be solely a function of how active your particular network is–if you have a lot of Facebook friends frequently checking whatever kind of public messaging system they’ve got, then this is an effective way to get someone, anyone, to call your cell phone; if you don’t have an active network, it doesn’t matter what site you’re using, you’re still just shouting into the virtual abyss.
BUT, overall number of users on any site is probably going to affect the activity level of any individual user’s personal network. So it may be that Facebook is where it’s at. We’ll see.
If you want to see my Facebook or MySpace profiles, I’ve added them to the sidebar under “the rest of me.”
And finally, on a rather different note, I’ve been meaning to post a poem I wrote a few years ago that is all about internet social networks, really: Love song for girl in chatroom #2
(It was the second love song, not the second chatroom.)
—
*Obviously it’s happened more than twice, outside of elevators. But twice in them.
The first time was an LJ friend who recognized me at the Midwest American Academy of Religion regional conference–actually, she said something to another guy, who came up to me in the elevator and said, “Excuse me. Are you… cabellicious?” So we’ve learned a lesson about what kind of internet handles we might not want to use.
**It was in my bathroom. Don’t ask me.